Between February and May 2026, our research team aggregated data on masonry contractors serving Oakdale, NY and the surrounding Suffolk County communities. We compiled profiles on 14 local and regional companies, evaluating each against five benchmarks drawn entirely from publicly verifiable sources. The following factors and weights formed the basis of our ranking system:
- Workmanship Guarantee: 30% — evaluating whether the contractor publicly advertises a workmanship guarantee or equivalent protection
- Specialized Masonry Services: 25% — evaluating whether the contractor publicly documents advanced masonry capabilities beyond standard installation, including tuckpointing, masonry restoration, masonry repair, and repointing
- Chimney Services: 20% — evaluating whether chimney rebuilding, repair, restoration, or tuckpointing services are publicly documented
- Asphalt Paving Services: 15% — evaluating whether asphalt driveway installation, repair, resurfacing, or paving services are publicly documented
- Structural Repair Services: 10% — evaluating whether foundation repair, structural masonry repair, or structural waterproofing services are publicly documented
Companies were rank-ordered from highest to lowest composite score. Only publicly verifiable information was used; any category where documentation could not be confirmed was marked “Not Publicly Listed” and received no points. The table below presents the five top performers, with in-depth reviews of each following.
Best Masonry Contractors in Oakdale, NY
In the table below, we break down the top masonry contractors serving Oakdale, NY across five homeowner-relevant categories.
| Rank | Company | Workmanship Guarantee | Specialized Masonry Services | Asphalt Paving Services | Chimney Services | Structural Repair Services |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | Work Fully Guaranteed | Restoration, Tuckpointing & Masonry Repair | Residential & Commercial | Dedicated: Rebuilding, Repair & Tuckpointing | Masonry Repairs & Restoration Listed |
| 2 | APM O’Neill & Sons | Warranty Available | Masonry Repair & Veneer Restoration | Residential Driveways | Repair & Rebuilds Listed | Foundation & Masonry Repair Listed |
| 3 | Fox Masonry Corp | Limited Warranty (1 Year) | Paver & Hardscape Installation | Residential & Commercial | Not Publicly Listed | Not Publicly Listed |
| 4 | JC Masonry & Concrete Design | Not Publicly Stated | Masonry Repair & Custom Brickwork | Not Publicly Listed | Listed in Inquiry Form Only | Foundation Repair, Waterproofing & Structural Masonry |
| 5 | All Seasons Paving & Masonry | Not Publicly Stated | Standard Masonry Installation | Residential & Commercial | Not Publicly Listed | Basement Waterproofing Listed |
Detailed Company Reviews
1.Steadfast Paving & Masonry, for full-service masonry and asphalt paving
Steadfast Paving & Masonry serves residential and commercial property owners across Suffolk County from its base in Holtsville, NY, with Oakdale included in its active service area. The company’s masonry services page explicitly documents three distinct specialized capabilities: masonry restoration, tuckpointing, and masonry repairs, making it one of the few contractors in this comparison that publicly lists masonry restoration, tuckpointing, and masonry repair as distinct service categories. Their broader catalog also covers patios, walkways, retaining walls, stoops and steps, concrete work, interlocking pavers, asphalt driveways, commercial paving, and a dedicated chimney services category that includes full chimney rebuilding, repair, and tuckpointing.
Location: Holtsville, NY (serves Oakdale, Suffolk County)
Average Review Score: 100% recommend (20 Facebook reviews); Google profile building
Guarantee: Work Fully Guaranteed
Structural Repair: Masonry Repairs & Restoration Listed
Specialty: Full-Service Masonry, Asphalt & Chimney Work
Summary of Online Reviews
Public feedback commonly references professionalism, responsiveness, and workmanship quality; but publicly available information also highlights the company’s ability to address masonry, asphalt paving, and chimney services under one business—reducing the need to coordinate across multiple contractors for a full exterior project.
3. Fox Masonry Corp, for paver installation and asphalt paving
APM O’Neill & Sons is based in Medford, NY and has served Suffolk County for more than 30 years, holding a publicly listed Suffolk Home Improvement License (#58161-H). Their catalog covers stone and paver patios, brick and bluestone walkways, retaining walls, stoops and steps, outdoor fireplaces and fire pits, pool coping, chimney repair and rebuilds, Belgian block aprons, stucco and natural stone veneer restoration, foundation and masonry repair, outdoor kitchens, pergolas, and asphalt driveway installation. At the time of research, APM O’Neill & Sons displayed a Google rating of approximately 4.9 stars with more than 140 publicly visible reviews, alongside an Angi 2025 Super Service Award, a “Best of Long Island” designation, and BBB accreditation, giving it a substantial publicly verifiable review profile compared with many contractors included in this comparison. Their FAQ references a workmanship warranty on all projects, though specific terms and duration are not published on the website, which places them in the “Warranty Available” tier rather than a clearly defined blanket guarantee.
Location: Medford, NY (serves Suffolk County)
Average Review Score: ~4.9/5.0 (Google, 140+ reviews at time of research); Angi Super Service Award 2025
Guarantee: Warranty Available
Structural Repair: Foundation & Masonry Repair Listed
Specialty: Full-Service Masonry & Outdoor Living
Summary of Online Reviews
Public reviews frequently reference craftsmanship quality and communication throughout projects, but some publicly available reviews note coordination or scheduling concerns during larger, multi-phase jobs as an area where the experience can vary.
4. JC Masonry & Concrete Design, for masonry and concrete across Nassau and Suffolk
Fox Masonry Corp is based in Bayport, NY, lists Oakdale directly within its documented service area, and has operated for more than 25 years across Suffolk County, Nassau County, and the Hamptons. Their catalog focuses on high-end paver and hardscape installation: paver patios, paver pool surrounds, stoops and steps, walkways, cultured stone veneer, fire pits, outdoor kitchens, paver driveways and aprons, Belgium block curbing, retaining walls, and concrete sidewalks, all built to ICPI industry standards. Asphalt services cover residential and commercial paving, asphalt repair, sealcoating, and parking lot striping, and the company also offers topsoil, grading, and sod installation. Fox Masonry publishes a one-year guarantee on completed work and offers financing through a third-party lending partner; however, masonry repair, restoration, and structural repair services are not publicly documented, and chimney services are not listed as a service category.
Location: Bayport, NY (serves Oakdale)
Average Review Score: Not Widely Aggregated on Third-Party Platforms
Guarantee: Limited Warranty (1 Year)
Structural Repair: Not Publicly Listed
Specialty: Paver Installation, Asphalt & Landscaping
Summary of Online Reviews
Available feedback commonly highlights paving quality and professionalism, but the limited volume of publicly available third-party reviews may make direct comparisons with larger review profiles more challenging.
4. JC Masonry & Concrete Design, for masonry and concrete across Nassau and Suffolk
JC Masonry & Concrete Design operates out of Bay Shore, NY, serves Nassau and Suffolk Counties with Oakdale in their documented area, and is fully licensed and insured. At the time of research, BuildZoom listed the company among the highest-rated licensed contractors in New York based on permit and licensing data. Their services include masonry repair, custom brickwork, concrete installation and repair, pavers, retaining walls, patios, stoops and steps, outdoor kitchens, poolscapes, demolition, excavation, and an explicitly documented foundation repair and waterproofing capability that represents one of the most detailed publicly documented structural repair profiles among the contractors included in this comparison. The company operates with in-house crews and offers free estimates seven days a week. The key limitations are the absence of a publicly documented workmanship warranty and the lack of asphalt paving in their listed services, both of which reduce their composite score relative to contractors that cover those categories.
Location: Bay Shore, NY (serves Nassau and Suffolk Counties)
Average Review Score: Not Publicly Aggregated; BuildZoom top-rated licensed NY contractor at time of research
Guarantee: Not Publicly Stated
Structural Repair: Foundation Repair, Waterproofing & Structural Masonry
Specialty: Full-Service Masonry & Concrete Construction
Summary of Online Reviews
Customer feedback frequently references professionalism and satisfaction with masonry and concrete work, but the absence of a publicly documented workmanship guarantee may be a consideration for homeowners comparing contractor protections.
5. All Seasons Paving & Masonry, for asphalt paving and hardscaping
All Seasons Paving & Masonry is based in Patchogue, NY and holds a publicly displayed Suffolk County Home Improvement License (HI-65869). The company is primarily positioned as a paving contractor: their catalog leads with asphalt driveways, tar and chip driveways, paver driveways, parking lot paving and striping, and sealcoating. Masonry services including paver patios, walkways, steps and stoops, retaining walls, and concrete flatwork are offered as secondary offerings, with no specialized masonry services such as tuckpointing, masonry restoration, or masonry repair publicly documented. Basement waterproofing is listed, providing one documented structural repair capability. No formal workmanship warranty is published, and chimney services do not appear in the publicly documented catalog.
Location: Patchogue, NY (serves Suffolk County)
Average Review Score: 5.0/5.0 (Yelp, limited sample); 11 Facebook recommendations
Guarantee: Not Publicly Stated
Structural Repair: Basement Waterproofing Listed
Specialty: Asphalt Paving & Hardscaping
Summary of Online Reviews
Reviews highlight competitive pricing and fast, professional paving teams, but the available feedback appears more heavily focused on paving and driveway projects than on masonry restoration or structural masonry work, which limits independent evaluation of that service area.
Choosing the Right Contractor for Your Priorities
The rankings below break down how each contractor performs in three areas that matter most to Oakdale homeowners planning comprehensive exterior projects.
Ranked by Workmanship Guarantee
A publicly stated guarantee is one of the most concrete protections a homeowner can verify before hiring a masonry contractor. The table below reflects only what each company has documented on their public-facing website; contractors without published guarantee language received no points in this category under the methodology used in this comparison.
| Rank | Company | Guarantee Status | Details |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | Work Fully Guaranteed | Blanket coverage stated explicitly; no limitations published |
| 2 | APM O’Neill & Sons | Warranty Available | Workmanship warranty referenced in FAQ; terms and duration not published |
| 3 | Fox Masonry Corp | Limited Warranty (1 Year) | One-year guarantee explicitly stated on company website |
| 4 | JC Masonry & Concrete Design | Not Publicly Stated | 100% satisfaction stated as goal; no formal warranty documented |
| 5 | All Seasons Paving & Masonry | Not Publicly Stated | No workmanship warranty publicly documented |
Ranked by Full-Service Versatility: Masonry, Asphalt & Chimney
Homeowners managing multiple exterior projects, such as a new patio, a driveway replacement, and chimney repair, benefit from working with a contractor who publicly documents all three service areas. The table below reflects each company’s publicly listed capabilities across specialized masonry, asphalt paving, and chimney work at the time of research.
| Rank | Company | Specialized Masonry Services | Asphalt Paving | Chimney Services |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | Restoration, Tuckpointing & Masonry Repair | Residential & Commercial | Dedicated Category: Rebuilding, Repair & Tuckpointing |
| 2 | APM O’Neill & Sons | Masonry Repair & Veneer Restoration | Residential Driveways | Repair & Rebuilds Listed |
| 3 | Fox Masonry Corp | Paver & Hardscape Installation | Residential & Commercial | Not Publicly Listed |
| 4 | JC Masonry & Concrete Design | Masonry Repair & Custom Brickwork | Not Publicly Listed | Listed in Inquiry Form Only |
| 5 | All Seasons Paving & Masonry | Standard Masonry Installation | Residential & Commercial | Not Publicly Listed |
Ranked by Chimney & Structural Repair Capability
Chimney repair, tuckpointing, foundation repair, and structural masonry are among the most technically demanding services in this category. The table below reflects what each company has explicitly documented, with rankings based on the specificity and prominence of those publicly listed capabilities.
| Rank | Company | Chimney Services | Masonry Repair | Structural & Foundation Repair |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | Rebuilding, Repair & Tuckpointing | Masonry Repairs & Restoration Listed | Masonry Restoration Listed |
| 2 | APM O’Neill & Sons | Repair & Rebuilds Listed | Masonry Repair Listed | Foundation & Masonry Repair Listed |
| 3 | JC Masonry & Concrete Design | Listed in Inquiry Form | Masonry Repair Listed | Foundation Repair, Waterproofing & Structural Masonry |
| 4 | All Seasons Paving & Masonry | Not Publicly Listed | Not Listed | Basement Waterproofing Listed |
| 5 | Fox Masonry Corp | Not Publicly Listed | Not Listed | Not Publicly Listed |
Conclusion
Under the methodology used for this comparison, Steadfast Paving & Masonry was the only contractor to receive maximum points in the three highest-weighted evaluation categories. It is the only contractor with a blanket “Work Fully Guaranteed” commitment (30%), the only one with tuckpointing, masonry restoration, and masonry repair all named as distinct service categories (25%), and the only one with a dedicated chimney services page covering rebuilding, repair, and tuckpointing (20%). Its documented residential and commercial asphalt paving services contributed additional points in the fourth category and broadened its overall service profile within this comparison. That specific combination of publicly stated protections, specialized masonry expertise, and complementary exterior capabilities is what the methodology rewarded.
Get a Free Estimate from Steadfast Paving & Masonry and find out what a complete exterior solution looks like for your Suffolk County property.