Average ROI on Home Improvements: October 2026

Between July and October 2026, the team at Steadfast Paving & Masonry tracked return-on-investment outcomes across 85 completed residential and commercial projects throughout Suffolk County, New York, cross-referencing project costs and post-completion appraisal data with national benchmarks from Zonda’s 2025 Cost vs. Value Report and regional figures from Long Island contractors. As licensed paving and masonry professionals serving Suffolk County homeowners, we observe firsthand how exterior improvements affect property values in one of New York’s most competitive real estate markets. The data below combines national averages with local Suffolk County estimates to help homeowners evaluate their next improvement project with confidence.


Average ROI on Home Improvements — October 2026

Not all home improvements return the same value at resale. The table below ranks 17 common projects from highest to lowest average ROI, drawing from national and regional data. Paving and masonry projects—including driveways, patios, and masonry work—consistently rank among the stronger mid-range investments available to homeowners.

The Average ROI on Home Improvements — 2026

Home Improvement Project Avg. Project Cost Est. Value Added at Resale Average ROI
Garage Door Replacement $4,700 $11,900 253%
Steel Entry Door Replacement $2,400 $5,100 212%
Manufactured Stone Veneer $11,800 $24,100 204%
Fiber-Cement Siding Replacement $21,500 $23,900 111%
Minor Kitchen Remodel $28,500 $31,900 112%
Attic Insulation Upgrade $2,600 $2,520 97%
Wood Deck Addition $18,300 $17,100 93%
Retaining Wall Installation $9,500 $8,550 90%
Composite Deck Addition $25,100 $21,900 87%
Front Walkway & Entry Steps $7,200 $6,120 85%
Paver Patio Addition $9,000 $7,200 80%
Asphalt Driveway Installation $9,500 $7,125 75%
Chimney Repair/Restoration $5,500 $4,125 75%
Paver Driveway Installation $13,000 $9,100 70%
Bathroom Remodel (midrange) $22,000 $14,300 65%
Major Kitchen Remodel $78,000 $41,300 53%
Primary Suite Addition $152,000 $75,000 49%

Swipe sideways to view the full table →

National figures sourced from Zonda’s 2025 Cost vs. Value Report and the NAR Remodeling Impact Report. Paving and masonry figures reflect regional Suffolk County contractor data cross-referenced with national benchmarks.

Key Findings:

  1. Exterior improvements hold 8 of the top 10 spots by ROI. Projects that strengthen a home’s visual presentation from the street return more at resale than interior renovations in every market surveyed—a pattern that has held across the Cost vs. Value Report for multiple consecutive years.
  2. Lower-cost exterior projects outperform expensive interior ones on a dollar-for-dollar basis. A $4,700 garage door replacement returns 253%, while a $152,000 primary suite addition returns just 49%. Buyers respond to what they see first.
  3. Paving and masonry projects cluster in the 70–90% ROI range, placing them among the strongest mid-range investments for homeowners—particularly in Suffolk County, where buyer competition for move-in-ready exteriors remains strong year-round.

Exterior Improvements with the Highest Average ROI — 2026

Exterior improvements consistently outperform interior renovations at resale. Real estate professionals attribute this to the outsized role curb appeal plays in buyer first impressions and listing price decisions. The table below isolates exterior-specific projects and includes the primary reason each performs well in the current market.

The Average ROI on Exterior Home Improvements — 2026

Exterior Project Avg. Cost Avg. ROI Primary Value Driver
Garage Door Replacement $4,700 253% Dominant visual impact, low project cost
Steel Entry Door Replacement $2,400 212% Security signal and aesthetic upgrade
Manufactured Stone Veneer $11,800 204% Architectural character and durability
Fiber-Cement Siding Replacement $21,500 111% Weather protection and modern finish
Wood Deck Addition $18,300 93% Defined outdoor living space
Retaining Wall Installation $9,500 90% Slope control and usable yard creation
Composite Deck Addition $25,100 87% Low-maintenance outdoor square footage
Front Walkway & Entry Steps $7,200 85% Curb appeal and buyer safety signal
Paver Patio Addition $9,000 80% Outdoor room creation, lifestyle appeal
Chimney Repair/Restoration $5,500 75% Removes buyer inspection red flags
Asphalt Driveway Installation $9,500 75% Clean, functional first impression
Paver Driveway Installation $13,000 70% Premium material and elevated curb appeal

Swipe sideways to view the full table →

Key Findings:

  1. The top three exterior improvements all return more than 200% ROI, meaning homeowners more than double the money invested. This is driven by a combination of high buyer sensitivity to exterior appearance and the relatively low cost of each project type.
  2. Hardscaping improvements—retaining walls, walkways, patios, and driveways—occupy the 70–90% ROI range. While they don’t hit triple-digit returns, they provide both aesthetic and functional value that buyers can evaluate from the curb and confirm during any walkthrough.
  3. Chimney repair and restoration, often treated as a maintenance item rather than an investment, delivers 75% average ROI while also preventing the inspection findings that can reduce sale prices or cause transactions to fall through. For homeowners with active fireplaces, chimney services represent a high-yield, low-visibility upgrade before listing.

Average ROI on Paving & Masonry Projects in Suffolk County, NY — 2026

Suffolk County’s housing market is among the most competitive on Long Island. Buyers in Patchogue, Smithtown, Bay Shore, Ronkonkoma, and surrounding communities expect move-in-ready exteriors, and properties with clean, well-maintained paving and masonry tend to receive stronger offers and shorter time-on-market. Paving and masonry projects in this region return above the national average, driven by high baseline property values and strong buyer demand.

The data below was compiled from Steadfast Paving & Masonry’s project records (July–October 2026), Long Island-specific real estate appraisal data, and regional contractor benchmarks from the Brothers Paving & Masonry backyard cost study and JC Masonry’s Long Island ROI analysis.

The Average ROI on Paving & Masonry Projects in Suffolk County, NY — 2026

Project Type Typical Cost Range Est. Value Added Avg. ROI Best Fit For
Retaining Wall Installation $8,000–$18,000 $7,200–$16,200 85–95% Sloped lots, drainage issues
Tuckpointing / Masonry Restoration $2,000–$7,000 $1,800–$6,300 80–90% Aging brick and block structures
Front Walkway & Entry Steps $5,000–$12,000 $4,250–$10,800 80–90% All residential properties
Chimney Repair / Rebuilding $3,000–$12,000 $2,400–$10,200 75–90% Homes with active fireplaces
Paver Patio Addition $8,000–$18,000 $6,400–$14,400 75–85% Backyard entertainment focus
Paver Driveway Installation $12,000–$20,000 $8,400–$15,000 70–80% High curb appeal goal
Asphalt Driveway Installation $7,000–$13,000 $5,250–$9,750 70–75% Functional, cost-effective upgrade
Commercial Parking Lot Paving $15,000–$50,000 $10,500–$37,500 65–75% Commercial / investment properties
Concrete Flatwork $3,000–$8,000 $1,800–$5,000 55–65% Utility surfaces and side paths

Swipe sideways to view the full table →

Regional figures reflect Suffolk County, NY market conditions as of October 2026. Values are estimates based on contractor project records and regional appraisal data and may vary based on property size, material selection, and neighborhood comp values.

Key Findings:

  1. Retaining walls deliver the highest ROI in this category, returning 85–95% on average. In Suffolk County, where many residential lots include gently sloped terrain, a well-built retaining wall addresses both drainage and usable space concerns—two factors that buyers and inspectors weigh heavily.
  2. Walkway and entry step improvements return up to 90% at resale while carrying some of the lowest cost-per-square-foot of any paving project. For homeowners preparing to list, a refreshed front entry signals maintenance and care to buyers before they reach the front door.
  3. Asphalt driveways return 70–75% in Suffolk County—a reliable result for one of the region’s most requested exterior upgrades. For homeowners not ready to invest in a paver installation, asphalt paving offers a clean, durable finish at a fraction of the cost, with consistent market performance at resale.

Requesting a Copy of This Report

The data in this report draws from Steadfast Paving & Masonry’s tracked project outcomes (July–October 2026), Zonda’s 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, NAR Remodeling Impact data, and regional Long Island contractor benchmarks. If you’d like to request a PDF copy of this report or discuss a paving or masonry project on your property, you can reach out to our team here.


Last updated: October 30, 2026


Sources

  1. Steadfast Paving & Masonry, Internal Project ROI Tracking Study. Brentwood, NY. October 2026.
  2. Zonda Media / Journal of Light Construction, 2025 Cost vs. Value Report. September 2025.
  3. National Association of REALTORS®, Remodeling Impact Report, 2025.
  4. JC Masonry & Concrete Design, “Top Masonry Upgrades That Increase Property Value in Long Island Homes,” 2025.
  5. Brothers Paving & Masonry, “Complete Backyard Renovation Cost on Long Island 2026,” 2026.
  6. Home Improvement Research Institute (HIRI), Home Improvement Spending Outlook, 2026.