Choosing a paving contractor in Selden involves more than comparing estimates. The contractor you hire will determine how long your driveway, patio, or walkway holds up, how well any issues get resolved after the job closes, and whether the quoted price reflects what you actually pay.
This guide compares five contractors serving Selden and the surrounding Suffolk County area, scored across five factors relevant to residential homeowners. Each company was evaluated using publicly available information from their official websites, third-party review platforms, and business registration records. Results are organized below, starting with the top-ranked contractor and ending with a breakdown of the best choices for specific homeowner priorities.
- Average Review Score (22%): Customer feedback from verified third-party platforms, reflecting real-world satisfaction across multiple completed projects
- Services Offered (23%): The breadth of paving, masonry, and exterior services each contractor publicly documents for residential clients
- Selden Service Coverage (20%): Whether the contractor holds a physical Selden presence, a dedicated service page, or explicitly lists Selden in its coverage area
- Pricing Transparency (15%): Publicly documented estimate policies, pricing disclosures, and any price-stability or price-match commitments
- Workmanship Guarantee (20%): Specific, publicly stated protections covering completed work, including any stated warranty duration
The full rankings and company reviews follow.
The Best Paving & Masonry Contractors in Selden, NY (2026)
| Company | Average Review Score | Services Offered | Selden Coverage | Pricing Transparency | Workmanship Guarantee | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | 5.0/5 on Facebook (35 reviews); 5.0/5 on Yelp (1 review); 55 Google reviews on file via TrustIndex (star average not independently confirmed) | Asphalt & paver driveways, patios, walkways, Belgian block, retaining walls, concrete, chimney rebuilding & repair, tuckpointing, masonry restoration | Dedicated Selden masonry & paving pages; explicitly names Selden; Suffolk County coverage | Free in-home estimates; beat-or-match pricing policy documented on Selden page | 1-year written guarantee stated on official website and Selden page |
| 2 | Summit Paving & Masonry | 4.9/5 on HomeAdvisor (82 reviews); 5.0/5 on BirdEye (201 reviews); 4.7/5 on Yelp (3 reviews) | Asphalt & paver driveways, patios, walkways, stoops, retaining walls, drainage, outdoor kitchens, fire pits, sealcoating, commercial paving, waterproofing, masonry | Nassau & Suffolk County; based in Centereach (bordering Selden); no dedicated Selden page identified | Free no-obligation estimates; transparent pricing cited on website | No specific warranty terms identified; HomeAdvisor listing indicates no warranty is offered |
| 3 | Landscaping & Masonry by G. Pellegrino | 5.0/5 on Angi (41 reviews); 4.4/5 on Yelp (7 reviews) | Patio construction, stoops, walkways, retaining walls, landscape design, sprinkler systems, lawn care, waterfalls & water gardens | Physical Selden address (3 Donna Ct); long-established local presence | Free quotes available; no detailed pricing policies publicly published | 1-year workmanship warranty stated on company About Us page |
| 4 | Goodfellas Paving & Masonry | 22 Google reviews; TrustIndex-verified average above 4.5 | Asphalt driveways, patios, walkways, stoops & steps, stone masonry, brick work, brick repointing, chimney repairs, stucco, roofing, siding, waterproofing, foundation work | Dedicated Selden service page; contact page lists a Ronkonkoma address | Free consultation and personalized estimate; no specific pricing published | “Stands behind every job”; no specific warranty term publicly documented |
| 5 | Old Castle Paving & Masonry LI | 3.9/5 on Yelp (33 reviews) | Asphalt & paver driveways, patios, walkways, stoops & steps, concrete, parking lots, stone walls, overlays, basement waterproofing | Physical Selden address (1070 Middle Country Rd); Long Island service area | Free estimates; “30-day price promise” stated on website | “All work fully guaranteed”; no specific term published |
Company names and factor labels are abbreviated in the table above to fit the page; see the write-ups below for full detail.
Steadfast Paving & Masonry, for Selden homeowners who want a documented guarantee and pricing commitment
Steadfast Paving & Masonry serves residential and commercial properties across Suffolk County, with a dedicated Selden service page that explicitly names the community and outlines masonry and paving services tailored to Selden homeowners. The company’s documented service catalog covers asphalt and paver driveways, patios, walkways, Belgian block borders and aprons, retaining walls, concrete, chimney rebuilding and repair, tuckpointing, and masonry restoration. A 1-year written guarantee, stated on both the company’s main website and its Selden page, provides homeowners with specific, documented protection after project completion. Steadfast also publicly documents a beat-or-match pricing policy on its Selden page, committing to match or beat comparable quotes from licensed contractors.
- Best For: Homeowners in Selden and across Suffolk County who want paving and masonry work handled by a company with a dedicated local service page and documented guarantee terms
- Paving & Masonry Expertise: Asphalt and paver driveways, patios, walkways, Belgian block, retaining walls, and concrete work
- Additional Services: Chimney rebuilding and repair, tuckpointing, and masonry restoration
Summary of Online Reviews
Available reviews for Steadfast are generally positive, with recurring mentions of fair pricing, professional crew behavior, and clean project execution. One reviewer described the experience as “quality work at a fair price.” Multiple reviewers cite Miles by name as communicative and knowledgeable, and at least one notes the crew completed two projects efficiently in a short timeframe, but Steadfast’s Selden page covers masonry specifically, so homeowners with larger asphalt-only projects should confirm full scope and availability before scheduling an estimate.
Summit Paving & Masonry, for homeowners near Centereach who want the widest service catalog and largest review base
Summit Paving & Masonry is based at 152 Oxhead Rd in Centereach, a community that borders Selden within Suffolk County, making it one of the more geographically relevant options for Selden homeowners in this comparison. The company serves residential and commercial clients across Nassau and Suffolk counties, with a wide documented service catalog: asphalt driveways, paver driveways, patios, walkways, stoops, retaining walls, drainage, outdoor kitchens, fire pits, sealcoating, commercial paving, and waterproofing, among others. Summit’s review profile combines high ratings with substantial volume across multiple platforms: 4.9 across 82 HomeAdvisor reviews and 5.0 across 201 BirdEye reviews.
- Best For: Homeowners near Centereach and across Nassau and Suffolk counties who want the widest documented service catalog and a large, consistently rated review base across multiple platforms
- Paving & Masonry Expertise: Asphalt and paver driveways, patios, walkways, stoops, retaining walls, and masonry
- Additional Services: Drainage, outdoor kitchens, fire pits, sealcoating, commercial paving, and waterproofing
Summary of Online Reviews
Summit’s public review sample is substantial, with 82 HomeAdvisor reviews and 201 BirdEye reviews identified at the time of research. Available reviews are generally positive, with recurring mentions of clear communication from Jerry, the company principal, on-time project delivery, and pricing described as fair. One reviewer noted that a paver driveway installed in 2011 “still looks like new today 16 years later.” The Yelp presence is limited to three reviews, but HomeAdvisor’s public listing for Summit indicates no warranty is offered, so homeowners should ask directly about post-completion protections and get any commitment in writing before signing a contract.
Landscaping & Masonry by G. Pellegrino, for Selden homeowners with landscaping or hardscape-integrated projects
Landscaping & Masonry by G. Pellegrino is a family-owned company with a physical address at 3 Donna Ct, Selden, NY 11784, and over 40 years of experience serving Long Island residential clients. The company’s About Us page states a 1-year workmanship warranty, placing it alongside Steadfast as one of the two contractors in this comparison with a publicly documented warranty term. Documented services cover patio construction, stoops and walkway installation, retaining walls, landscape design, sprinkler systems, and waterfalls and water gardens.
- Best For: Selden homeowners whose project involves landscape design or hardscape features alongside paving elements, and who want a long-established, warranty-backed local contractor
- Paving & Masonry Expertise: Patio construction, stoops, walkways, and retaining walls
- Additional Services: Landscape design, sprinkler systems, lawn care, and waterfalls and water gardens
Summary of Online Reviews
Available reviews for G. Pellegrino on Angi are generally positive, with recurring mentions of service quality, fair pricing, and a smooth process from start to finish. One reviewer described the experience as “excellent quality of service, fair price, and just a stress-free pleasant experience.” The Yelp rating of 4.4 across 7 reviews is somewhat lower, though the overall sentiment remains favorable, but most of the detailed Angi reviews reference landscaping and hardscape design rather than asphalt or structural paving work, so homeowners with paving-heavy projects should confirm current scope before requesting a quote.
Goodfellas Paving & Masonry, for homeowners consolidating multiple exterior trades with one contractor
Goodfellas Paving & Masonry maintains a dedicated Selden service page and explicitly lists Selden among the communities it serves. The company’s contact page lists a Ronkonkoma address (500 Peconic St, Apt 22B), which homeowners should confirm when discussing project logistics. The company offers a broad exterior service catalog covering asphalt driveways, patios, walkways, stoops and steps, stone masonry, brick work, brick repointing, chimney repairs, stucco, foundation work, roofing, siding, and waterproofing. The company carries a TrustIndex verified badge, which requires a Google review average above 4.5.
- Best For: Homeowners with wide-ranging exterior renovation needs who want to consolidate paving, masonry, and other trades with one contractor
- Paving & Masonry Expertise: Asphalt driveways, patios, walkways, stoops and steps, stone masonry, brick work, and brick repointing
- Additional Services: Chimney repairs, stucco, roofing, siding, waterproofing, and foundation work
Summary of Online Reviews
Available reviews for Goodfellas are generally positive, with recurring mentions of fair pricing, on-time project completion, and attentive communication. One reviewer noted that Mike and the team were brought back for a second project after a successful first engagement, describing “an amazing job again.” The available review sample is smaller than that of several competitors, so homeowners should ask for project references relevant to their specific job type and confirm the service address and coverage area before proceeding.
Old Castle Paving & Masonry LI, for Selden homeowners who want a documented price promise on standard paving work
Old Castle Paving & Masonry LI lists a physical address at 1070 Middle Country Rd in Selden, NY 11784, on its contact page, placing it within the community this comparison targets. The company offers paving and masonry services to residential and commercial clients across Long Island, with a documented service list that includes asphalt and paver driveways, patios, walkways, stoops and steps, concrete, parking lots, stone walls, overlays, and basement waterproofing. The company’s website states that “all work is fully guaranteed,” and also advertises a “30-day price promise,” one of the clearest documented pricing-related commitments identified among the contractors reviewed here.
- Best For: Selden homeowners who want a locally addressed contractor with a documented pricing promise, for standard driveway, concrete, and patio projects
- Paving & Masonry Expertise: Asphalt and paver driveways, patios, walkways, stoops and steps, and concrete
- Additional Services: Parking lots, stone walls, overlays, and basement waterproofing
Summary of Online Reviews
Customer feedback for Old Castle on Yelp is mixed. More favorable reviews describe a professional crew and competitive pricing, but the 3.9 average across 33 Yelp reviews is lower than the ratings shown for the other companies in this comparison, so homeowners should read recent reviews carefully and ask for references before committing.
Best For: Choosing the Right Paving & Masonry Contractor in Selden
We also broke down the top contractors into three categories based on project priorities, pricing transparency, and overall service breadth.
Best for Homeowner-Focused Projects
| Company | Standout Strength | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | A dedicated Selden service page, 1-year written guarantee, beat-or-match pricing policy, and consistently favorable reviews for crew communication and project care make Steadfast a well-documented option for homeowners who want clarity on what happens after the job is done |
| 2 | Landscaping & Masonry by G. Pellegrino | A physical Selden address, over 40 years of local experience, a 1-year workmanship warranty, and a 5.0 Angi rating across 41 reviews make G. Pellegrino a strong option, particularly for landscape-integrated exterior projects |
| 3 | Old Castle Paving & Masonry LI | A Selden address at 1070 Middle Country Rd, a documented guarantee on all work, and a 30-day price promise give Old Castle a meaningful local footprint; the lower Yelp rating means homeowners should review recent feedback before deciding |
| 4 | Goodfellas Paving & Masonry | A dedicated Selden service page and generally favorable reviews for attentive communication and clean project execution; the smaller review sample and Ronkonkoma contact address are factors homeowners should confirm before committing |
| 5 | Summit Paving & Masonry | A strong residential track record and high review volume across platforms, though the absence of a documented warranty and a Centereach base rather than a dedicated Selden presence give other options an advantage for homeowners with a strictly local priority |
Best for Financially Transparent Project Planning
| Company | Standout Strength | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Old Castle Paving & Masonry LI | The publicly stated 30-day price promise is one of the clearest documented pricing-related commitments in this comparison; paired with free estimates, it offers price-stability documentation the other contractors don’t explicitly publish. Homeowners should confirm exact terms directly with Old Castle |
| 2 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | A beat-or-match pricing policy documented on the Selden service page and free in-home estimates represent a combination of competitive pricing commitment and accessibility that stands out among the five contractors reviewed here |
| 3 | Summit Paving & Masonry | Transparent pricing is cited on the Summit website alongside a free, no-obligation estimate process; the combination supports more confident pre-project financial planning |
| 4 | Goodfellas Paving & Masonry | A free consultation followed by a personalized estimate provides a structured two-step process that gives homeowners a clearer picture of what they are agreeing to before work begins |
| 5 | Landscaping & Masonry by G. Pellegrino | Free quotes are available, though the company website provides limited detail around the estimate process or specific pricing transparency policies relative to the other contractors in this comparison |
Best for Comprehensive Paving and Masonry Needs
| Company | Standout Strength | |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Summit Paving & Masonry | The widest documented paving and masonry service list in this comparison: asphalt and paver driveways, retaining walls, patios, walkways, stoops, drainage, outdoor kitchens, fire pits, sealcoating, commercial paving, and waterproofing all appear in publicly reviewed materials |
| 2 | Goodfellas Paving & Masonry | A broad documented exterior catalog that extends beyond paving and masonry into roofing, siding, stucco, and foundation work; homeowners with projects spanning multiple exterior trades may find this breadth useful, though scope should be confirmed for each category |
| 3 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | A solid residential catalog covering asphalt and paver driveways, patios, walkways, Belgian block, retaining walls, chimney rebuilding and repair, and masonry restoration; a practical fit for most standard exterior paving and masonry projects in Selden |
| 4 | Old Castle Paving & Masonry LI | A solid paving and masonry catalog that includes private roads, stone walls, and basement waterproofing; a practical option for homeowners who need standard driveway, concrete, and patio work with a locally based contractor |
| 5 | Landscaping & Masonry by G. Pellegrino | Patios, stoops, walkways, and retaining walls are documented, but the primary service emphasis is landscaping and outdoor design rather than structural paving; homeowners with asphalt-heavy or commercial paving needs should confirm scope before proceeding |
Conclusion
For Selden homeowners evaluating paving contractors, the five companies in this comparison offer meaningfully different profiles across the factors that affect real project outcomes. If review volume and documented service breadth are the priority, Summit Paving & Masonry holds a strong public record across multiple platforms and one of the widest service catalogs in this group, though its lack of a documented warranty is worth weighing carefully. Homeowners who want a Selden-based contractor with a warranty may find Landscaping & Masonry by G. Pellegrino a strong alternative, particularly for projects with a landscaping or hardscape design component.
Steadfast Paving & Masonry stands out overall for its combination of a publicly documented 1-year written guarantee, a beat-or-match pricing commitment, and dedicated Selden service pages for both masonry and paving. That combination of local specificity, post-project protection, and price accountability is what distinguishes it within this comparison. Before selecting any contractor, request written estimates from at least two companies, ask specifically about warranty terms in writing, and confirm that your project type falls within the contractor’s current scope.
To start with Steadfast, call (631) 948-2286 or visit steadfastpavingandmasonry.com to request a free estimate.