Most Suffolk County homeowners searching for a paving contractor are dealing with more than one project at a time. A cracked driveway might need asphalt work. An aging patio may need masonry attention. A deteriorating chimney cap may need repointing before the next winter. Finding one contractor who can handle all of it, one who actually serves your part of the county, takes more research than most homeowners expect.
Between April and July 2026, we analyzed over 20 paving and masonry contractors actively serving Suffolk County homeowners. We collected data from each company’s official website and scored each contractor using a five-factor weighted ranking system. The results are organized below, starting with our top-ranked contractor and ending with a breakdown of the best choices for specific homeowner needs.
- Driveway Paving (25%): Breadth of driveway paving capabilities, including material options, installation types, and surface repair services
- Masonry Services (15%): Depth and variety of masonry offerings, including patios, retaining walls, walkways, stonework, and hardscape
- Chimney Services (25%): Whether the company explicitly offers chimney rebuilding, repair, repointing, or maintenance as a documented service
- Free Estimates (15%): Whether the company publicly states that it provides free, no-obligation estimates to prospective clients
- Service Area (20%): Specificity and depth of named Suffolk County service coverage, including geographic proximity to residential communities
The full rankings and company reviews follow.
The Best Paving Contractors in Suffolk County, NY (2026)
| Company | Driveway Paving | Masonry Services | Chimney Services | Free Estimates | Service Area | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | Asphalt & paver installation, resurfacing, overlays, concrete | Patios, walkways, retaining walls & masonry restoration | Rebuilding, repair, repointing & maintenance | Offered on every service page, no obligation | Holtsville base; Patchogue, Smithtown, Bay Shore & more |
| #2 | APM O’Neill & Sons | Asphalt replacement, seal coating, resurfacing & parking lots | Custom paver patios, retaining walls & outdoor living | Chimney repair & masonry stonework | Free estimates; on-site consultations with 3D layout | Medford base; 12 named South Shore communities |
| #3 | Brothers Paving & Masonry | Asphalt, paver & concrete options; drainage solutions included | Patios, pool hardscape, retaining walls & outdoor kitchens | No dedicated chimney services documented | Free estimates; all projects warranty-backed | Bay Shore base; all of Nassau & Suffolk County |
| #4 | All Purpose Paving | Asphalt driveways, sealcoating & oil-and-stone options | Patios offered; full masonry scope not publicly detailed | No chimney services publicly documented | Free, detailed estimates with step-by-step breakdown | Riverhead base; county-wide Suffolk County coverage |
| #5 | All Suffolk Paving & Masonry | Asphalt paving, overlays, Belgian block & aprons | Stone & block walls, patios, paver steps & bluestone | General chimney masonry referenced; no dedicated chimney service pages | Not publicly stated on current website | Selden base; all of Suffolk County, North Shore focus |
Steadfast Paving & Masonry, for central Suffolk residential paving and masonry
Steadfast Paving & Masonry operates out of the Holtsville and Selden area and serves residential and commercial properties across central and south Suffolk County. The company offers asphalt paving, masonry, and chimney services through a single locally based team, combining multiple exterior services under one contractor. Projects range from new asphalt driveway installations and paver work to retaining walls, patios, and full chimney rebuilding. Free estimates are prominently offered throughout the website, with a direct contact form on every service page.
- Best For: Homeowners in central and south Suffolk County, including Holtsville, Patchogue, Smithtown, Bay Shore, Ronkonkoma, Medford, and Sayville, who need asphalt paving, masonry, and chimney work completed by one local team without coordinating multiple contractors
- Paving Expertise: Asphalt and paver driveway installation, parking lot paving, resurfacing, overlays, and concrete work, with service pages emphasizing proper site preparation, accurate grading, and drainage planning as part of every installation
- Additional Services: Patios, walkways, retaining walls, masonry restoration, chimney rebuilding, chimney repair, chimney repointing and tuckpointing, and routine chimney maintenance, each supported by a dedicated service page on the company’s website
Summary of Online Reviews
Customer reviews commonly highlight “quality workmanship,” “professional and accommodating crews,” and “competitive pricing,” but what consistently stands out is Steadfast’s ability to handle asphalt paving, masonry, and chimney services through one locally based Suffolk County team, reducing the need to coordinate multiple contractors for exterior projects.
APM O’Neill & Sons, for premium Suffolk masonry and asphalt paving**
APM O’Neill & Sons has operated in Suffolk County since 1996 and publicly lists its Suffolk Home License (No. 58161-H) on its website. The company serves a named roster of South Shore communities from its Medford base and holds a 2025 Angi Super Service Award alongside BBB accreditation. Project scope runs from asphalt driveway installation to custom paver patios, retaining walls, outdoor living spaces, and chimney work. On-site consultations include 3D layout planning, and APM O’Neill states that its own crew manages all permits and installation from start to finish.
- Best For: South Shore and central Suffolk County homeowners seeking a contractor with a 30-year operating history, a publicly listed license number, and a premium masonry and hardscape portfolio built on authorized brand installations
- Paving Expertise: Asphalt driveway installation and full replacement (binder and topcoat), seal coating, resurfacing, and parking lot paving, with authorized installer status for Techo-Bloc, Nicolock, Cambridge, and Unilock paving products
- Additional Services: Custom paver patios, retaining walls, outdoor kitchens, fireplaces, pool decks, masonry walls and stoops, chimney work, and koi ponds and water features, all designed and installed by an in-house crew
Summary of Online Reviews
Customer reviews commonly highlight “detailed project planning,” “high-quality masonry craftsmanship,” and “consistent professionalism,” but APM O’Neill may appeal to homeowners seeking a design-to-build approach with on-site consultations and premium hardscape options.
Brothers Paving & Masonry, for large-scale Long Island outdoor projects
Brothers Paving & Masonry operates out of Bay Shore and serves Nassau and Suffolk County with a team of 40-plus crew members and 20-plus trucks. The company is a certified installer of Cambridge Pavingstones and Nicolock Paving Stones, with additional installations available in Techo-Bloc and Unilock. All projects are described as warranty-backed on the company’s website. Brothers lists 11 distinct service categories covering everything from driveways and patios to pool hardscape, outdoor kitchens, and full backyard transformations.
- Best For: Homeowners across Long Island seeking a large, well-resourced contractor for complex paving, hardscape, and outdoor living projects that require significant crew capacity, premium materials, and multi-category coordination
- Paving Expertise: Asphalt, paver, and concrete driveway installation, driveway resurfacing, parking lot paving, sidewalk construction, drainage solutions, and concrete slabs, with certified installations for Cambridge and Nicolock products
- Additional Services: Paver patios, pool hardscape, retaining walls, walkways and entryways, stoops and porches, outdoor kitchens, fire pits, fireplaces, seating walls, and full backyard transformations across Nassau and Suffolk County
Summary of Online Reviews
Customer reviews commonly highlight “premium finished results,” “clean job sites,” and “high-quality materials,” but as with many larger contractors serving multiple markets, project availability may vary throughout the year.
All Purpose Paving, for multi-generational Suffolk County asphalt services
All Purpose Paving is a multi-generational, family-operated asphalt paving company serving all of Suffolk County from its Riverhead base. The company explicitly states on its website that it is licensed and insured, and describes its estimate process as transparent and detailed, with each step outlined before work begins. Its core focus is residential asphalt work, with services including driveway installation, sealcoating, and oil-and-stone driveway options. Free estimates are offered to all prospective clients.
- Best For: Suffolk County homeowners who need a straightforward, county-wide asphalt paving service with a licensed and insured, family-operated team and a clear, no-pressure estimate process
- Paving Expertise: Asphalt driveway installation, sealcoating, oil and stone driveways, and residential and commercial paving across all of Suffolk County, with a customer-focused estimate process that outlines every step before any work begins
- Additional Services: Patios. Additional masonry services are not publicly detailed on the company’s website at this time.
Summary of Online Reviews
Customer reviews commonly highlight “transparent pricing,” “straightforward estimates,” and “reliable county-wide scheduling,” but homeowners who also need masonry or chimney work alongside their paving project may need to work with another contractor, based on the services currently documented on the company’s website.
All Suffolk Paving & Masonry, for north shore asphalt and masonry work
All Suffolk Paving & Masonry is a BBB-accredited contractor based in Selden, serving Suffolk County with a stated primary focus on North Shore communities. The company offers a broad service menu spanning asphalt paving, masonry work, and drainage, with experience on both residential and commercial projects. Its explicitly stated service communities include East Setauket, Stony Brook, Mount Sinai, Miller Place, Port Jefferson, and Wading River. All Suffolk serves all of Suffolk County while maintaining this North Shore geographic focus.
- Best For: North Shore Suffolk County homeowners in communities such as East Setauket, Stony Brook, Port Jefferson, and Mount Sinai looking for an established, BBB-accredited contractor with a broad paving and masonry service menu
- Paving Expertise: Asphalt driveway installation, overlays, parking lot paving, aprons, Belgian block edging, gravel installation, and concrete walkways, with a stated primary focus on North Shore residential and commercial properties
- Additional Services: Stone and block walls, patios, paver steps, bluestone work, concrete walkways, paver firepits, and basement waterproofing
Summary of Online Reviews
Customer reviews commonly highlight “an established local presence,” “variety of paving and masonry services,” and “accommodating crews,” but homeowners located in central or south Suffolk County may find that All Suffolk’s primary focus on North Shore communities makes scheduling and proximity less convenient for their area.
Best For: Choosing the Right Paving Contractor in Suffolk County
We also broke down the top contractors into three categories based on project type, homeowner priorities, and specific situations.
Best by Project Type
| Project Type | Recommended Contractor | Standout Strength |
|---|---|---|
| Asphalt driveway installation | Brothers Paving & Masonry | Offers asphalt, paver, and concrete driveway types in one scope, with drainage solutions and warranty-backed workmanship included |
| Paving and masonry combined | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | One of the only contractors in Suffolk County with asphalt paving, masonry, and chimney services under one locally based team |
| Chimney repair or repointing | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | Four dedicated chimney service pages covering rebuilding, repair, repointing, and maintenance, not just a single line item in a service list |
| Custom paver patio or stonework | APM O’Neill & Sons | Authorized installer of Techo-Bloc, Nicolock, Cambridge, and Unilock; premium brand credentials documented on the company’s official website |
| Full backyard transformation | Brothers Paving & Masonry | 11 documented outdoor service categories supported by 40+ crew members and 20+ trucks for estate-scale project capacity |
| Sealcoating or asphalt maintenance | All Purpose Paving | Three generations of asphalt-specific expertise, with sealcoating as a dedicated service, not an add-on |
Best by What You Value Most
| What You Value | Recommended Contractor | Standout Strength |
|---|---|---|
| A contractor local to central Suffolk | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | Names six specific central and south shore communities on its website, with a Holtsville base that minimizes travel time across the service area |
| One team for multiple exterior services | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | One of the contractors in this comparison documenting asphalt paving, masonry restoration, and chimney services within a single service offering |
| Premium design-to-build craftsmanship | APM O’Neill & Sons | On-site consultations with 3D layout planning, permit management by its own crew, and 30 years of Suffolk County project history |
| Largest crew and project capacity | Brothers Paving & Masonry | 40+ crew members and 20+ trucks with a portfolio spanning waterfront estates and full-scale Nassau and Suffolk County renovations |
| Straightforward asphalt-only service | All Purpose Paving | Licensed and insured multi-generational asphalt specialist with a step-by-step estimate process designed for homeowners who want clarity upfront |
| North Shore Suffolk County location | All Suffolk Paving & Masonry | BBB-accredited with a stated primary focus on East Setauket, Stony Brook, Port Jefferson, and surrounding North Shore communities |
Best by Homeowner Situation
| Your Situation | Recommended Contractor | Standout Strength |
|---|---|---|
| Need driveway, patio, and chimney work | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | All three service categories fully documented and handled by one locally based team, with no need to coordinate separate contractors |
| First time hiring a paving contractor | Steadfast Paving & Masonry | Service pages outline preparation steps, materials, and expected outcomes, making it easy to understand the full scope before committing |
| High-end hardscape or estate project | APM O’Neill & Sons | 3D layout consultations, authorized premium material installations, and an in-house crew that handles permits through project completion |
| Large or complex outdoor renovation | Brothers Paving & Masonry | Publicly states a team of 40+ crew members and 20+ trucks, supporting large-scale outdoor projects with warranty-backed delivery across Long Island |
| Asphalt maintenance or sealcoating only | All Purpose Paving | Multi-generational asphalt specialist that is licensed and insured, with a transparent process that avoids upselling beyond the homeowner’s stated need |
| Located on the North Shore of Suffolk | All Suffolk Paving & Masonry | Long-established, BBB-accredited contractor with a stated North Shore geographic focus and a service menu built specifically around those communities |
Conclusion
Suffolk County homeowners have solid options when it comes to paving and masonry contractors. The right choice depends on what your property actually needs, where you are in the county, and whether you’re managing one project or several at once.
For homeowners in central and south Suffolk County who need asphalt paving, masonry, and chimney services handled by a single local team, Steadfast Paving & Masonry is the strongest overall fit. Its combination of service range, geographic coverage, and residential focus distinguishes it within this comparison.
If you’re ready to move forward with a project, contact Steadfast Paving & Masonry for a free estimate.